Growth Response of Cucumber (Cucumis sativus) to Organic and Inorganic Fertilizers under Shade House Conditions

Authors: Fredrica Whyte; Joneshia Bryan-Thomas; Grover Samuels; Vincent Wright; Patience Bazuaye-Alonge
DIN
IJOEAR-SEP-2025-2
Abstract

The germination and growth of Cucumis sativus were studied by comparing the efficacy of selected organic (rabbit manure, goat manure, and fermented fruit tea) and inorganic Nitrogen Phosphorus Potassium (NPK) 11-22-22 fertilizers at a rate of 40g applied in 2 intervals. Cucumis sativum was grown for 3 months under shade house conditions in grow bags using a randomized complete block design (RCBD) with five treatments and four replications. Each block represented 40 plants with 8 plants per treatment. Although there was no statistical significance between the organic manures within the parameters tested, all organic manure was significantly different from the NPK in their effects. The fermented fruit tea treatment had the highest seedling growth rate as well as the highest germination percentage. The fruit tea also had the highest germination rate index after 5 days however the rabbit manure had the highest overall germination rate index as well as the highest number of plants flowering at the start of measurement. The NPK showed the lowest values overall. One-way analysis of variance was utilized for group comparison with significance noted at P<0.05 in germination rate and flowering. These comparisons were performed on essential germination rate and percent along with the time of flowering. This study shows that these organic treatments can have a positive effect on the germination percentage, germination rate, and plant growth of cucumbers. This research has provided valuable and statistically significant information to augment claims that organic fertilizers such as rabbit and goat manures along with fermented fruit tea, offer essential nutrients and can be used as a suitable alternative to inorganic fertilizers for those farmers wishing to move into organic farming of cucumbers.

Keywords
Inorganic fertilizer fruit tea goat manure rabbit manure
Introduction

The importance of soil fertility to plant growth is widely studied and is one of the most important factors for crop production. Soil quality which is sometimes used interchangeably with soil fertility is defined as the capacity of the soil to function within the boundaries of ecosystems to sustain biological activity, maintain environmental quality and promote plant and animal health (Krishna, 2002). Where plant production is concerned, soil fertility is a combination of the chemical, physical, mechanical and biological aspects of the soil that contributes to agricultural yield (Krishna, 2002). According to Krishna (2002) Soil fertility and crop management are the two most important ingredients of modern agricultural activity, he defined soil as the medium for crop production where the texture, soil composition, and aggregation along with other factors such as aeration, are essential considerations. The inclusion of soil additives to support the cultivation of crops is often indispensable to farming and many farmers rely heavily on fertilizer or other enriched material to support the growth of their plants. Soil additives may be in the form of fertilizers or other soil-enhancing inputs that affect the various production aspects of plants. In addition to soil additives, microorganisms play an important role in crop production whether positively or negatively. Bacteria and fungi in the soil may act as great advantages or disadvantages to crop growth and yield.

Plants take up nutrients easily from fertile soils and where there is biological balance, productivity is high, this allows for healthy plants to grow in a healthy environment (Sari et al. 2007). Deficiency due to the scarcity of single or multiple nutrients occurs regularly in agricultural soils and is made worse by intensive cropping practices assoil fertility drives crop productivity and thus crop yields. The scarcity of essential nutrients limits crop yield if not replenished. Fertilizer utilization in agriculture has assisted in increased crop production and helped in spreading agricultural zones to once infertile lands (Krishna 2002). Plants need more than just inorganic fertilizers, as the soil is a living system it needs to have a balance of organic, inorganic, and microorganisms as well as other important structural components.

Many countries around the world (IFOAM Organics Europe 2020) are focusing on sustainable agriculture and food safety (FAO, IFAD, UNICEF, WFP and WHO. 2019). A major focus for many sustainability-conscious farmers is to reduce the number of inorganic fertilizers used on the farm. Commercial farmers are therefore looking at different ways of improving yield and balancing the fertility of the soil. Some amendments studied (Minu Singh 2014), (Sari 2007), (N. Karagiannidisa 2011), (Tarraf W 2017), (Abay Ayalew 2012) and used effectively in other countries include a mixture of NPK and other fertilizers, compost, raw animal manure, microorganisms (IFOAM Organics Europe 2020).

The use of inorganic fertilizers has been the norm for avery longtime and we seethe effects of the depleted soil fertility from the use of inorganic fertilizers on our sugarcane (Chi L. 2017) and banana (Zake Y.K. 2000) production. Alternate ways of nourishing the soil are therefore necessary, these alternatives must also be available and adaptable to local conditions. These ways must be proven, economical, and can support the long-term fertility of the soil. There is a need for formal research and adequate testing of locally available soil nutrient sources.

As the world battles the unpredictable climatic variations it has become increasingly obvious that each nation needs to ensure its adequate food security. Global impacts such as the sudden decline in global trade and the uncertainty in the continuation of the crisis brought on by this pandemic, many countries are using more of their resources internally as opposed to exporting them (The World Bank 2020). The need for sustainable agriculture and food security ties in well with the United Nation's Sustainable Developments goals number 2, 6, 12, 13, and 15 (FAO, IFAD, UNICEF, WFP and WHO. 2019); Sustainable development goals: # 2: Zero Hunger, # 6: Cleaner Water and Sanitation, # 12: Responsible Consumption and Production, # 13: Climate Action, # 15: Life on Land. And therefore augments the need for such a local assessment as is being proposed. In an FAO 2019 report on‚ the state of food security and nutrition in the world, safeguarding against economic slowdowns and downturns‘ the authors highlighted that there is a trend in severe food security in the world, this they say is an indication of increasing hunger (FAO, IFAD, UNICEF, WFP and WHO. 2019). This trend started before the current COVID19 pandemic and has thus been exacerbated. The report warned of; slowing and stalled economic growth in many countries, including emerging and developing economies; episodes of financial stress; elevated trade tensions, declining commodity prices, and tightening financial conditions. All these warnings are a reality in this current time, not only for Jamaica but for many countries of the world. To make recommendations, the FAO pointed to the need for individual countries to implement short-term measures such as strengthening savings capacity when the economy is growing, as well as implement longer-term measures to ‘invest wisely during periods of economic booms to reduce economic vulnerabilities and build capacity to withstand and quickly recover when economic turmoil erupts” (FAO, IFAD, UNICEF, WFP and WHO. 2019). The FAO called for the transformation of the agriculture and food systems to include the types and quality of food production. If this was necessary before December 2019, we are now in a serious state of urgency to consider our food systems.

We can no longer rely on food, fertilizers, and other recourses coming from the USA and China, these are restricted by the internal need of these countries, trade tensions, and poor purchasing power among other factors (The World Bank 2020). Besides, if the FAO'scall for the transformation of the agriculture and food system to include the 'quality of the food' (FAO, IFAD, UNICEF, WFP and WHO. 2019) is to be considered at all, we must improve our food production to ensure food security. We are already constrained by our low storage capacity and must therefore find ways of producing food year-round. Locally grown foods when consumed also contribute to sustainability.

This research aims to test and identify sustainable methods of increasing the crop yield of Cucumis sativus, through the use of organic fertilizer treatments.

Conclusion

Germination is a critical phase in the lifecycle of a plant. This study shows that organic fertilizer treatments can have a positive effect on germination, plant growth and flowering. There is consistent evidence to show that organic manure can be highly competitive with inorganic fertilizers when used for germination, plant growth and plant yield (Jalaluddin M. and Hamid M. 2011, Vaithiyanathan T. and Sundaramoorthy P. 2016). Vaithiyananthan found that although triple phosphate had a greater germination rate than organic manure (cow dung), the cow dung gave a faster growth in the plants (Vaithiyanathan T. and Sundaramoorthy P. 2016). Jalaluddin found that the highest germination (99%), root length, shoot length, fresh weight and dry weight were seen in combined biofertilizer application (Jalaluddin M. and Hamid M. 2011).

Organic sources such as the ones used in this research as well as green manure and compost not only increase soil fertility but also add organic matter to the soil (Ram M. 2012, Adhikari A. 2020). Organic manure provides organic acids that help dissolve soil nutrients and make them available for the plants (Obasi N.,et al. 2013). Each type of organic fertiliser used has its benefits to the growth of the plant throughout its life cycle. Care needs to betaken in ensuring that plants are given the correct balance of macro and micronutrients that will aid in promoting optimal plant performance and increasing fruit yield. This research has provided valuable and statistically significant information to augment claims that organic fertilizers such as rabbit and goat manure along with fermented fruit tea offer essential nutrients and can be used as a suitable alternative to inorganic fertilizers for those farmers wishing to move into organic farming.

The shade in the greenhouse was a limitation to the normal development of the cucumber plants. Additional follow-up research is recommended in an area with sufficient light as well as recommendation to conduct yield measurements with these treatments.

ACKNOWLEDGMENT We are extremely grateful to the people who supported this research whether by providing technical expertise or giving their labor or material towards this research.

We would like to express our deepest gratitude to the Team at the NCU Farm, Donald Sturgeon, Robin Morgan, and his wife as well as Robert Christie.

We are grateful to Dorienne Rowan-Campbell for her technical advice on how to prepare our fermented fruit tea. Zachen Campbell for providing the rabbit manure and Mr. Fabian Thomas for his assistance during the project. CONFLICT OF INTEREST The authors declare that there is no conflict of interest.

Agriculture Journal IJOEAR Call for Papers

Article Preview